The Daily View: A question of compromise
Your latest edition of Lloyd’s List’s Daily View — the essential briefing on the stories shaping shipping
CRITICS of the IMO’s Net-Zero Framework have been clear about what global green regulation should not do.
“The green transition will not succeed simply by making shipping more expensive,” Malta’s transport minister Chris Bonett argued this week.
Russia has similarly called for a five-year delay, warning that the framework risks raising transport costs and food prices while encouraging owners to pay penalties rather than invest in alternative fuels. Iran this week submitted a lengthy list of critical observations, calling for greater simplicity, transparency and stronger safeguards against unintended consequences.
These concerns deserve consideration. The problem is that opposition to the framework has so far produced more criticism than alternatives.
If governments are serious about decarbonising shipping through a global mechanism, the debate cannot revolve solely around what should be removed from the proposal. The harder question is what should replace it.
The uncomfortable reality is that shipping’s energy transition will almost certainly involve higher costs. The challenge is not whether those costs exist, but how they are distributed in a way that is fair, transparent and effective.
That does not mean accepting the current framework as fit for purpose. Far from it. Major elements remain unfinished, including long-term emissions targets, funding arrangements and key assumptions underpinning the treatment of alternative fuels.
Nor is the political divide narrowing. Supporters of the framework face continuing resistance from a vocal group of largely oil and gas-exporting states, while pressure is growing on the IMO to secure agreement before negotiations lose momentum entirely.
Reports of negotiation fatigue among delegates suggest the temptation of a compromise deal is growing. Maritime history offers little comfort here. Regulations designed primarily to secure consensus often satisfy nobody and achieve little.
The risk is not simply higher costs. Poorly designed regulation could consume industry resources, undermine confidence in the IMO and fail to deliver meaningful emissions reductions. The protracted struggle to reform the Carbon Intensity Indicator already illustrates how difficult it can be to fix rules that lack broad support or practical effectiveness.
There is broad agreement that shipping’s decarbonisation framework must be global. But being global is not enough. It also needs to work.
That will require both supporters and opponents to move beyond criticism and engage seriously with the difficult compromises needed to make the transition happen.
Declan Bush
Senior reporter, Lloyd’s List
Click here to view the latest Lloyd’s List Daily Briefing.
